
I have to say while I'm no Altman completest (if I were you'd think I would have seen "Nashville" before now) I've always had a soft spot in my heart for him.
I am one of the 20 people on the face of the planet who actually enjoyed and still enjoy his widely panned "Popeye." I remember reading the opening line of a review of that film in my big book of Leonard Maltin- "The beloved sailor man boards a sinking ship..."
So it was with a fair amount of optimism that I popped the film into my DVD player and embarked on a journey that would leave me haggard, weary, and watching the clock.
All the Altman signatures are here in possibly their purest form. A Gargantuan Cast? Check. Dialogue and conversations that seem to bump into and crowd out each other from scene to scene? Check. Story? Missing in Action.
Watching an Altman picture can be akin to standing in the middle of a crowded party and listening to the bits and pieces of the conversations around you. You only hear part of what was said, and there's always a lot of other noise and other conversations trying to drown it out.
Now this is a hallmark of his work, and I've enjoyed in other films such as "MASH" and "The Player." But here it's just distracting.
His penchant for large casts of characters works against him here too. We are introduced to so many people and we spend so little time with each of them, it's hard to care about anyone.
One of the first sights we see is the giggle inducing sight of former "Laugh In" cast member Henry Gibson in a sequined shirt, scarf, and obscenely large mutton chops singing some patriotic claptrap about the bicentennial. It's quickly explained that Gibson is an country western star, and a major league SOB, and then we're off to another studio and more characters.
Now none of this would matter much if there was an engaging story to keep me interested But I found all the story lines thin and incoherent.
There's a story about a country singer going through a nervous breakdown, a gospel singer, her put upon husband and their two deaf kids, Gibson's sob and his political aspirations, a British reporter doing a story on the Nashville scene, along with Jeff Goldblum, who wears glasses that wouldn't be out of place on Gloria Steinem and rides an easy rider chopper so large and cartoonish it looks like a giant big wheel.
There's also a political van touting a presidential campaign that seems to pop up every few minutes or so. I think it was supposed to help tie things together the way the announcements over the loudspeaker set the mood in "MASH." But I have to say I was left cold by its heavy handed political speechifying.
But the film only seemed to spring to life during the engaging musical sequences.
After an hour I was checking my watch, and by the time it mercifully came to an end two and a half hours later I was exhausted and weary and glad it was over.
Buy it, Rent it, Watch it on Cable, or Skip it: Skip It